Education and PWDs

 Gender-based violence against Women With Disabilities in Nigeria

Women with disabilities suffer more trouble than their male counterparts. It is easier for a male with disability to be quickly employed than women with disabilities. Women with disabilities’ health are often not prioritised unlike other women without disabilities. These are facts and figures in Nigeria. But beyond all these daily challenges, abuses suffered by women with disabilities are grossly untold. There are constant sexual and gender violence not reported, this is especially common with speech, hearing and visually impaired women. Their assailants know they cannot see or shout for help.

The issue of financial exclusion is also rampant, it will take great and personal determination of a woman with disabilities to be co-opted into the financial system.

In terms of health, women with disabilities suffer more to get attention. For women with mobility issues, finding their ways to hospital and health care facilities can be a herculean task. Assessing health facilities again is a big issue and ability to communicate with medical personnel plus verbal assault women with disabilities receive from nurses are untold.

Centre for disability and Inclusion Africa recent Persons with Disabilities stakeholders’ policy dialogue which ran across the 6 states that made up the South West geo political zone of Nigeria with estimated 49 Million populations and about 4 million Persons with disabilities gave us first hand exposure to some of the challenges Persons with disabilities with special interest in what Women with Disabilities go through.

 From Lagos to Osun, to Oyo, Ekiti and Ondo states, the cry is almost the same.  Ishola Elizabeth, Women leader of Joint Association of Persons with Disabilities(JONAPWD) maintained that women with disabilities face many assaults which are results of lack of adequate infrastructure which propel people to carry married women with disabilities in some facilities, marital challenges of society discouraging men without disabilities from marry a woman with one, Hospital attendants and medical personnel ill-treating women with disabilities among others.

In Oyo state, Women leader of JONAPWD, Alabi success decried absence of adequate accessibility tools, devices which hinder effectiveness of persons with disabilities with particular emphasis on Women with disabilities. The situation was not different in Ekiti state where the Women leader of JONAPWD in the state, Mrs Ogunkuade actually broke down in tears with regards to abuses suffered by women with disabilities especially when it comes to marriage.

According to her “Women with disabilities are often taken advantage of when they need a man to marry. Often they fall in the hands of deceivers who often use and dump them or in many cases use their nude pictures to illegally take money from them”.

On employment issues, Ogunkuade and Ishola said, women with disabilities need economic empowerment support too, so they can become useful to society.

The case is not different in Ondo state where Busayo Ademeko, Women leader of JONAPWD affirmed challenges women with disabilities face in the area of marriage. Finding a spouse is often difficult, especially if a woman with disabilities prefers a man without disabilities. Aside from this, discriminations are rife in the treatment of women with disabilities with regards to finding employment, assessing health and medical care. The level of harassment and verbal assaults are unimaginable.

Fear of Women with Disabilities with regards to seeking Justice

But with regards to seeking legal redress for injustice, many security Agencies, especially Officers in charge of PWDs desks across the South West state from Osun to Ekiti and Ondo maintained, lack of willingness or boldness of women with disabilities to come forward and make reports are some of the reasons such injustice go unpunished.

ASC khadijat Bakare, Osun state Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps’ (NSCDC)PWDs desk officer affirmed in many cases, NSCDC had to go out of its way to seek redress for the injustice meted to women with disabilities when they hear of one but many of them would rather keep quiet.

In Ekiti DSC Adejuwon, who is the PWDs desk officer for NSCDC Ekiti maintained “Women with Disabilities need to come out and report abuses for security agencies to help”. According to her there are protocols of reporting abuses before Security Agencies are involved, if that is not followed, they will be incapacitated.

In Ondo, SC Femi Igbekele, NSCDC Ondo state PWDs Officer did say, “There may be challenges for some women with disabilities to get redress but these can be lessened if the victim steps out and report”. He cited a case of a speech impaired lady who was unjustly denied her rights because of her inability to share her side of the story. Femi Igbekele said he had to go and search for a sign language interpreter so as to get the woman’s side of the story and eventually she was released.

But more importantly, to actually forestall unnecessary harassment, Evangelist Olu Adegoke, former JONAPWD chairman in Oyo State, Mrs Folasade Arise, Disability Affairs board chairperson in Ondo State, Mrs Fatola, Executive Secretary, Ondo state Disability Affairs board, Mr Ibiyale, director in the Ministry of Women Affairs and Social inclusion Oyo state all believed there is need for women with disabilities to know their rights and demands for them.

In most cases, according to all of these individuals, many victims had accepted their rights without knowing they all have rights to protection from abuses. Also, there is one common factor why some women keep quiet, their abusers are often close persons or carers and the thoughts of not having them again if picked up by security agencies often make them become silent.

Discriminations against Persons with Disabilities Acts 2019, State Disability Bills and State Disability Boards

In 2019, the federal government under President Buhari signed into law Discrimination Against Persons with Disabilities Acts(DAPDA) which was passed into law by the National Assembly in 2018 and this followed with establishment of the National Commission for Persons with Disabilities. For most states who had passed Disability Bills, Lagos, Oyo, Ondo, Ekiti among many others, the situation is almost the same- low awareness about the law and its agencies.

Only Lagos seems to have an Agency that is known by majority even though some of its activities are still being questioned with regards to efficiency.

Oyo state passed disability bills in 2021 but the Agency activities are still in the infancy stage with no office structure. Ekiti state is not different as much. The conflicting nature of executive order that established the State disability board prior to Disability Bill promulgation had created a dichotomy that is not allowing effectiveness of the Agency.

It is also noted by concerned PWD stakeholders in Ekiti that Disability board members are just being selected and paid for doing nothing as they work part time. Yes, the state has a Senior Special Assistant to the Governor on Disability matters.

Persons with disabilities can also be the problem

Up until recently, Persons with disabilities in Lagos, this include Women with disabilities, had cried out against exclusion and lack of concern of the management of the state’s Disability Agency, Lagos Office of Disability Affairs led by Mr Dare, towards issues affecting PWDs in the state. It took intervention of concerned stakeholders and media outcry to get Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu to remove Dare and appoint his   former Special Assistant on Disability, Adenike Oyetunde-Lawal in his stead.

Princess Folasade Arise, the Chair of Ondo State Disability Board in a conversation with NGNEWs once affirmed “Some Persons with disabilities can also be a clog in the wheel of progress for Persons with Disabilities especially Women With Disabilities”. This can be true in the light of the fact that Mr. Dare who used to head LASODA is also a person with disability

But for Princess Folasade Arise, her concerns go deeper than the likes of Mr Dare, in her words, as chair of the Disability Board in Ondo state, she had seen cases where a male person with disabilities, married to a woman with disabilities constantly abused their spouses. “How do we justify this?” Princess Arise asked? 

Which way forward?

Looking at the loopholes established above with regards to why Women with Disabilities abuses continued, it is easy to mitigate some of the issues. Women with disabilities must seek knowledge about their rights as well as be empowered to stand up for these rights. Economic empowerment coupled with fundamental rights as well as self-awareness of who they are as humans will help. 

The non-state actors in the PWDs community, which are the impaired, the affected and the concerned, must become active and collaborate. With this the community can put pressure on the state actor- policy makers and government to protect rights and privileges of women with disabilities in Nigeria

N.B The story, written by Yinka Olaito, was culled from www.nigeriagrassrootnews.com

READ MORE
Education and PWDs

Oyo State PWDs, Inclusion Community Stakeholders Policy Dialogue

While a disability bill is already enacted in the state with attendant setting up an Agency to oversee affairs of Disability matters in the state, public awareness and more especially PWDs community awareness is still very low. Majority of the public within the state are not aware the agency exists.  

The agency operations in itself is still in its infancy stage trying to gather momentum. Just recently, the agency just set up its administrative office but administrative staff are yet to be fully employed and given the fact that the provision of at least 50% of staff must be persons with disabilities continue to be a challenge. More importantly, finance has been a major factor.

Officials at the event- L-R Comrade Lawal, Executive Assistant to the Governor’s rep, Mr Akinsewa, repr Mr Ajilo Femi, chair JONAPWD oyo state, Evang, Olu Kayode, Rep of Barr. Adekambi, Mrs Temitope Labai, Women leader , Oyo state JONAPWD, Mr Yusuf Olatunji, Mr Ibiyale, rep Commissioner for Women Affairs

Panellists at the event

Above and many other issues were the major concerns of Oyo state Persons with Disabilities(PWDs), Inclusion Communities at the recently held Oyo State PWDs, Inclusion Stakeholders Policy Dialogues, which is part of the project of the centre to gather views of southwest Nigeria Disabilities caucus. The event was held at University of Ibadan hotel on Friday 26th January, 2024.

The event with the theme: Nigeria Inclusive Society: Accessibility, Exclusion and Social relationships” among many others was convened to create an avenue for collaboration, conversation around PWDs rights and their active participation in the society.

The event, which is organized as a panel session, has Hon. Toyin Balogun, the Oyo state Commissioner for Women Affairs and Social Inclusion as chairperson as well as the following as panellists:  Barr, kayode Adekambi, Director of Oyo state Board for Disability Affairs, Mr Ajilo Femi, Oyo state chair of Joint National Association of Persons with Disabilities(JONAPWD), Mrs Alabi Temitope Success, Women leader, JONAPWD, Oyo state as well as Mr  Yusuf Olatunji, former secretary-general of JONAWPD while Hon. Femi Timothy, Executive Assistant to the Governor served as special guest at the occasion.

The commissioner, through her representative, Mr Ibiyale, who is the director of rehabilitation in the Ministry, shared her Ministry appreciation with the organization for such a laudable project, emphasized state government’s commitment to issue of PWDs especially to Women with Disabilities and itemised ongoing efforts of her Ministry and that of the state’s government to make life better for PWDs in the state.

The panellists, participants made significant contributions to the dialogue which cut across accessibility, exclusion, social relationship issues, need to promote awareness of existence of Disability agency’s activities; need for transparency and accountability of the agency, needs for collaborations among the stakeholders among other salient issues. Find some of these below:

Key Recommendations

  1. There is need to train staff of   the nascent Oyo state Disability Board to understand its vision, mission and the modus Operandi. The board has to be self-sustainable to play its role.
  2. Working intimately with the media houses in Oyo State is important for correcting negative narratives, stereotypes and public awareness about disability.
  3. Local Government Office holders in Oyo state needs capacity building to understand disability and Inclusion and not exclude PWD in governance.
  4. PWDs need to speak up for themselves, be confrontational where necessary without being violent.
  5. JONAPWD need to position itself as a watchdog to the Oyo state Government in ensuring the inclusion of PWD in Oyo State.
  6. There is need for grassroots engagement, as JONAPWD need to be present and active in all local governments of Oyo state and the use of indigenous languages for awareness is important.
  7. Engage key stakeholders in accessibility and mobility such as structural engineer and Nollywood, financial institutions to correct negative narrative and take on where necessary.
  8. Role modelling and teamwork within the PWD community is important.
  9. Nollywood need a lot of briefing and change orientation in the stereotypical portrayal of PWDs in Nigerian films, Movies

Some of the participants

READ MORE
Education and PWDs

4 roadblocks to inclusive education in Nigeria

Inclusive education is the target set by the United Nations which is expected to be embraced globally. This is because it is founded on the basis of the principle of human rights which every individual, regardless of their physical, mental, or psychological condition, deserves. Quality education for every child leads to an empowered human resources at the national level.

Nigeria shares in this global aspiration, but its journey toward inclusive education faces a multitude of challenges.

According to UNICEF, roughly 95% of children with disabilities in developing countries, including Nigeria, do not attend school, with a disheartening possibility that 90% of them may never receive basic education in their lifetime. 

This distressing situation stems from various factors, including the prevalence of primary and secondary schools in Nigeria that present exclusive and inaccessible environments, lacking the physical and technological accommodations required for children with disabilities. Roadblocks to inclusive education in Nigeria include the following:

-Overreliance on Special Schools, where children with disabilities are confined, often to understaffed, under-equipped, and outdated facilities. This segregation perpetuates a sense of isolation and denies these children the opportunity to interact with their peers. Moreover, there is a lack of public awareness regarding the significance of inclusive education and the benefits it offers to all students.

-Conventional universities with no inclusive infrastructure: The challenges observed at the primary and secondary education levels are evident, but the focus on tertiary education for people with disabilities presents another pressing concern.

The continuous establishment of conventional universities in Nigeria overshadows the critical need for specialized institutions that can cater for the unique needs of students with disabilities. The absence of planned infrastructures for individuals with physical and intellectual challenges leaves a significant gap in the country’s education system.

Therefore, it’s essential for the government to consider creating such institutions, where students with disabilities can access higher education tailored to their specific needs.

Lack of required human capital/resources:  This challenge is worsened by the shortage of institutional and human capacity required for the effective implementation of inclusive education. The only college of special education in Sub-Saharan Africa, the Federal College of Education (Special) Oyo which is supposed to play a pivotal role in training educators who will teach individuals with disabilities faces challenges due to a shortage of manpower and resources.

Funding shortage: Prioritizing funding for special education is crucial if the government intends to ensure every person’s right to a quality education is upheld. That is irrespective of their abilities or disabilities. Nigeria bears the responsibility to ensure inclusive and equitable quality education for all its citizens, promoting lifelong learning opportunities.

Achieving inclusive education requires a collective effort from the government, educational institutions, civil society, and the general public. 

By addressing the challenges outlined in this piece among others and focusing on creating inclusive environments from the primary level to tertiary education can help Nigeria to work towards a more inclusive and equitable education system. Inclusivity is not just a goal; it is a fundamental right that must be upheld for the betterment of Nigerian society as a whole.

READ MORE
Education and PWDs

Women with Disabilities: quality education will reduce inequality

In a society where gender disparities have persisted for decades, education emerges as a powerful tool for pivotal change, paving the way for equality and progress.

Nigeria is a diverse nation with rich cultural traditions. However, like many countries around the world, it grapples with gender inequality. Women in Nigeria, especially the ones with disabilities,  have historically faced challenges in accessing education, health care, and economic opportunities. Discriminatory norms and practices have kept women and girls from amassing their full potential.

Education is a catalyst for change, and its role in women’s empowerment, inclusion and participation cannot be overstated. When girls and women are educated, it leads to positive outcomes for individuals, families, and society as a whole.

This highlights the transformative power of education in promoting gender equality. Educating women with disabilities enhances knowledge of their rights and empowers them against certain abuses. Educating women with disabilities may not solve all their problems but it clearly leads to significant progress in their economic empowerment. What are some of the values educating women with disabilities bring to the economy?

1. Breaking Cycles of Poverty: Education is a ladder out of poverty. Educated women are more likely to find employment, earn higher incomes, and contribute to their households’ economic well-being. In Nigeria, where poverty remains a pressing concern, educating women can have a profound impact on reducing poverty levels.

2. Improved Health Outcomes: Educated women tend to make more informed decisions about their health and the health of their families. They are more likely to seek prenatal care, vaccinations, and family planning services, leading to improved maternal and child health.

3. Enhanced Participation in Decision-Making: Education empowers women to participate actively in social, economic, and political spheres. It equips them with the knowledge and skills needed to engage in leadership roles and advocate for their rights.

4. Changing Gender Norms: Education challenges traditional gender norms and stereotypes. It encourages critical thinking and a broader perspective on gender roles, fostering a more inclusive and equitable society.

Nigeria has made significant strides in promoting women’s education in recent years. Government initiatives, such as the Universal Basic Education (UBE) program and the Girl-Child Education Unit, have aimed to increase girls’ enrolment and retention in schools. These efforts have yielded positive results, with more girls attending primary and secondary schools.

Furthermore, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and community-based organizations have played a vital role in bridging gaps in girls’ education, providing scholarships, mentoring, and support programs to empower girls across the country.

Despite the progress, challenges persist. Gender-based violence, early marriage, and cultural biases still hinder girls’ access to education. Moreover, inadequate infrastructure, insufficient resources, and security concerns in certain regions pose barriers to quality education.

To achieve true equality, Nigeria must continue investing in education, particularly for girls and women. This includes addressing the root causes of gender-based discrimination and violence and providing a safe and conducive learning environment for all.

The journey toward gender equality and women’s inclusivity is intrinsically linked to education. By investing in the education of girl children and women, Nigeria not only unlocks their potential but also sets the stage for a brighter, more equitable future. As we celebrate the progress made so far, let’s all remain committed to the path of educating, empowering, and uplifting Nigerian women—because their success is Nigeria’s success.

READ MORE